Impulse by Dave Bara

Impulse2Impulse is Dave Bara’s debut novel, published earlier this month by DAW. The cover copy starts off like this:

Following in the tradition of such top science fiction writers as Isaac Asimov, Arthur C. Clarke, Gordon Dickson, Frank Herbert and Joe Haldeman, Impulse, the first novel of The Lightship Chronicles, launches readers on a star-spanning journey of discovery, diplomacy and danger.

Based on the names mentioned in that paragraph, you can probably make some pretty decent assumptions about this novel… and you’d be 100% right. Impulse is aimed squarely at readers hankering for the Good Old Days of Science Fiction, when Old White Dudes wrote stories set in galaxies torn asunder by rival space empires, featuring proper dashing heroes and splashy space battles. This is as traditional a military science fiction novel as you’ll find. If that’s your cup of tea, Impulse may be something worth checking out for you.

Personally, I started getting annoyed early on, in the very first chapter no less, when Lieutenant Buzz Lightyear Peter Cochrane is summoned to his-father-the-Admiral’s office to learn that a “rogue hyperdimensional displacement wave” hit the brand new Lightship Impulse and two of its shuttles, causing multiple casualties including, wait for it, Peter’s girlfriend Natalie.

So. Flux-capacitor-grade technobabble? Check! Girlfriend fridged before we properly get started? Check! Oh, and did I mention that in the very first paragraph we learn that our hero’s older brother was killed in action three years back? I wasn’t kidding when I said “traditional”. Impulse is your everyday, all-purpose military SF space adventure. It’s a story that could be grafted almost perfectly onto the Star Trek universe to make for a decent if unsurprising episode or two.

So, issue number one is the, oh, let’s call it familiarity of the material. Issue number two is characterization. Aside from Peter “I’m going to impress my dad, redeem my dead brother, and avenge my dead girlfriend” Cochran, most of the characters are just empty shells walking around to move the plot along. In that sense, the influence of Isaac Asimov is really noticeable.

To be fair, there are some positives here too. For a debut author, Dave Bara really knows how to tell a story and keep it moving along. He infuses the story with a sense of enthusiasm that actually makes up for some of the issues outlined above: if you’re in the mood for straight-up space adventure brain candy, Impulse will deliver it.

The other bit I really like are the Earth Historians, a weird sect-like group that controls how advanced technology is used and distributed. Bara slowly trickles out information about their nature and motivations, but leaves just as many questions unanswered. I’m unlikely to read the second book in this series, but if I do, it would mostly be to find out more about the Historians.

Impulse by Dave Bara is a novel that, for better and for worse, hearkens back to the Golden Age of Science Fiction. If you’re willing to forgive a reliance on old tropes and thin characters to read a fast-paced, action-packed military space adventure, Impulse may be worth checking out. For me, the good didn’t outweigh the bad, so I doubt I’ll read further into the series.

Impulse is out now from DAW.

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Reviews, Science Fiction and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Impulse by Dave Bara

  1. Gerry M. Allen says:

    This review lacks polish in so many ways. Issac Asimov was a peace-nik and never wrote a lick of military science fiction. (If you think the Foundation series was military, there is no hope for you.) The snarky “Old White Dudes” is beneath you, or so I thought formerly. Star Trek was about peace; I suspect you know this, but had to say something to make your point.
    This entry exemplifies why blogs need editors.

    • Sorry you feel that way, Gerry. To answer your points:

      – I didn’t say Asimov wrote military SF. If you’ll take a look, you’ll see the reference was to his often wooden characterization, which I think even Asimov fans would agree with, for all the other great aspects of his writing. Foundation is definitely not military (and I never claimed it is).

      – Star Trek was about peace, yes, but as you know, it also featured a ton of military conflict. I happily stand by that reference.

      – The Old White Dudes bit (frankly inspired by the list of influences on the author’s website) is just a reference to years gone by, when that demographic tended to dominate the genre to near-exclusivity. I’m not condemning those authors as a group. I read and admire many of them. However, I am placing this new novel in that tradition, and I think the author wouldn’t be displeased with that comparison.

      – Finally, while my reviews for other venues are always edited by others, this blog is my own one-man-operation, so I’m my own editor here. My opinions are my own, presented for your reading pleasure. I gladly welcome discussion, criticism, and feedback.

  2. Paul Weimer says:

    I’ve been tempted to get it. I got the “golden age” vibe from the cover and synopsis. Your review confirms my pre-read impressions. Thanks Stefan.

  3. I agree. I read Impulse and gave it a rousing three stars. It was just action that drove the characters instead of characters driving the action.

  4. Unlike Gerry, I found this one my my favorite FBR reviews – a perfect mix of snark and well-deserved intellectualism. I’m tempted to read this just so we can banter about it and crack jokes.
    And yes, I may steal your Old White Dudes subgenre title. It’s perfect.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s