Scholar by L.E. Modesitt Jr.

Earlier this week, I posted a look back at the first three novels in L.E. Modesitt Jr.’s excellent Imager Portfolio series, and today I’m posting my review of last year’s Scholar, the fourth novel in the series and the start of its second arc about new protagonist Quaeryt. In a few days, I’ll post my review of the forthcoming new novel Princeps, as well as the long interview with the author I’ve been working on for the last few weeks…

In a pattern that’s by now familiar for L.E. Modesitt Jr., Scholar marks a new beginning in the Imager Portfolio series. The book is set several hundred years before the events portrayed in the three “Rhenthyll” novels Imager, Imager’s Challenge, and Imager’s Intrigue. (For a quick refresher on that trilogy, check out my recent look back at the series.) Because of this, Scholar shares no characters with the earlier novels in the series and can be read separately. However, if you haven’t read the Rhenthyll novels yet and are in the mood for some good, thoughtful fantasy, I still recommend reading them first, just so you can see the events of the new novel in the broader historical context this author likes to build for his fantasy worlds.

Scholar is set in a time when Solidar hasn’t been unified as one country yet. Rather than the stable and dominant realm we see in the Rhenthyll novels, the continent of Lydar is still split up into separate countries that are fighting for dominance. Bhayar, the young ruler of Telaryn, is trying to figure out why the province of Tilbor, conquered a decade ago by his father, still needs such a large armed presence to remain peaceful. He sends his friend Quaeryt to Tilbor to investigate and report back on the possibility of reducing the size of the province’s standing army.

Quaeryt, the main character of the novel, is a scholar. He’s also an imager, but he keeps his imaging ability mostly secret because, in this period before the Collegium Imago, imagers are still feared and frequently shunned. Like Rhenthyll from the Imager Portfolio’s earlier novels, he is a very recognizable L.E. Modesitt Jr. protagonist: intelligent, quiet, cautious but able to take decisive and sometimes surprising action when necessary. His name seems to mean something like “inquisitive” in one of this world’s languages, which is appropriate given his habit of asking incisive questions that frequently make people uncomfortable.

Quaeryt travels to Tilbor, having several adventures along the way. Once he arrives, he begins to investigate the local situation and the possible reasons that such a large military presence is still needed there, more than a decade after its conquest. He becomes part of life in the military structure in Tilbor, reports to his superiors, strikes up friendships, enjoys meals, and does extensive research into the history of Tilbor. The result is a novel that’s so instantly recognizable as an L.E. Modesitt Jr. story that it verges on the predictable, but as always it’s also full of interesting, well-drawn characters and fascinating world-building, making it well worth your time.

One difference between Quaeryt and Rhenthyll, the protagonist of the first three novels in the Imager Portfolio, is that Quaeryt, at least in this book, feels like a more stable character. Rhenn goes through a huge evolution: he starts a whole new life, learns a new profession, gradually becomes stronger and more important. Rhenn’s growth as a character is a big part of what made the first three Imager novels so enjoyable right from the start. By contrast, Quaeryt seems to have gone through his formative period well before the start of Scholar. He now appears as an already complete character who doesn’t change all that much throughout this story, aside from learning some new imaging skills. As a result, the emphasis here is much more firmly on plot than on character development, whereas the previous three novels struck a balance between the two. To be fair, this is only the first novel in what looks to be planned as a second sub-series of four books in the Imager Portfolio. There are indications that Quaeryt’s life is going to change again in the next novel, so there’s a good chance that we’ll see much more character growth in Princeps (May 2012).

Calling Scholar a prequel is technically correct but, given the author’s penchant for exploring the historical background of his fantasy worlds in great detail, it doesn’t tell the whole story. This is really a separate novel that happens to be set in the same world as, but several centuries before the first three books in the Imager Portfolio, allowing L.E. Modesitt Jr. to add considerable depth to this fantasy universe and place the events of the earlier novels in a solid historical context. Despite running along well-established patterns, this is another enjoyable novel by one of the genre’s most reliable and prolific authors.

This review was originally published at on November 8th, 2011.

This entry was posted in Fantasy, Reviews and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Scholar by L.E. Modesitt Jr.

  1. Pingback: Giveaway! Princeps by L.E. Modesitt Jr. | Far Beyond Reality

  2. I picked this one up at the library a few days before I read your review. I am ashamed to say that as much fantasy that I have read, I have never read anything by L.E. Modesitt, Jr. I am looking forward to reading it.

  3. Pingback: Princeps by L.E. Modesitt Jr. | Far Beyond Reality

  4. Pingback: Imager’s Battalion by L.E. Modesitt Jr. (includes a giveaway!) | Far Beyond Reality

  5. Pingback: Antiagon Fire by L.E. Modesitt Jr. (includes a giveaway!) | Far Beyond Reality

  6. Pingback: Rex Regis by L.E. Modesitt Jr. | Far Beyond Reality

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s